|
As Appeared in
InvestmentNews, May 17, 2004
On Greed, Social Investors Haven't Been Unconscious
By Amy Domini
I was pleased to see the headline ''We can't ignore corporate greed'' on the
Opinion page of your April 12 issue, but dismayed when I began reading. It is
simply untrue that socially conscious investors have ignored the issue of
excessive compensation for top corporate executives.
Over the years, Domini has filed or co-filed a number of shareholder
resolutions asking companies to disclose the salaries of employees at various
levels or calling for executive compensation to be linked to social and
environmental performance. Just last year, we co-sponsored a proposal at Cisco
(Systems Inc. of San Jose, Calif.) with a coalition of faith-based investors,
seeking a pay disparity report. In 2002, Mattel (Inc. of El Segundo, Calif.)
produced a report on how it determines severance packages for its top
executives, in response to a Domini proposal. That same year, in a letter to
the New York Stock Exchange, we highlighted excessive executive compensation as
''arguably the most critical single barrier to re-establishing investor confid
ence in our markets.'' Domini's proxy-voting guidelines have included detailed
criteria on levels of compensation for management and directors — including
stock options and severance pay — for many years.
Finally, ''excessive compensation'' is regularly noted in the corporate social
profiles produced by our social-research provider, KLD Research and Analytics
Inc. of Boston, and is a factor that helps determine which companies will be
included in the Domini 400 Social Index — the index on which the Domini Social
Equity Fund is based. For example, in 2002, Computer Associates (International
Inc. of Islandia, N.Y.) was removed from the index for awarding excessive
bonuses to its top officers.
Other socially responsible investment firms have done important work. This
season alone, resolutions on executive compensation were filed by Christian
Brothers Investment Services (Inc.) in New York, Boston Common Asset Management
(LLC) and the Calvert Group (Ltd. of Bethesda, Md.). The Interfaith Center on
Corporate Responsibility in New York and Boston-based Responsible Wealth, two
organizations with which social investment firms often work, have been raising
these issues for many years.
Contrary to your editorial, members of the socially responsible investment
community have been leaders on this critically important issue and deserve more
credit than you give them. To make a real difference, we need support from tra
ditional investors, who have generally been silent on these issues.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results
. The Domini Social Equity Fund is not insured and is subject to market risks.
You may lose money. Although the Domini Social Equity Fund is no-load, certain
fees and expenses apply to a continued investment and are described in the
prospectus. The composition of the Fund's portfolio is subject to change.
|